Greg Wilson/Anderson Observer
The South Carolina Supreme Court on Wednesday affirmed a decision invalidating Tonya Winbush's April election to Anderson City Council, leaving Seat 5 vacant seven months after voters cast their ballots — and raising concerns about a city attorney who presented evidence without being sworn in.
The court's 4-0 ruling, authored by Acting Justice Courtney Clyburn Pope, upheld the Anderson Municipal Election Commission's finding that Winbush did not reside in Ward 5 when she filed to run, and affirmed a circuit court order that had previously backed the commission.
Winbush won the April 7 election over Darryl Thompson, the son of retired longtime Councilwoman Beatrice Thompson, by an almost 2-to-1 margin — 135 votes to 68. Two days later, Thompson filed a protest challenging her residency. The commission voted April 17 to invalidate the results, finding Winbush had not abandoned her home at 741 Kings Road.
The commission relied on a paper trail that included a deed, county auditor records, vehicle registrations, utility records and a driver's license address. Winbush pointed to a lease and water-service application tied to 309 Morris Lane in Seat 5.
While affirming the result, the Supreme Court expressed unease with the procedures the commission used — particularly the role of city attorney Rame Campbell, who presented a notebook of documents to the commission without being sworn in as a witness.
The court declined to consider Campbell's unsworn statements and documents as evidence, saying it found the hearing procedures "concerning." It noted that Campbell's dual role as both an advocate and a witness raised concerns under Rule 3.7 of the Rules of Professional Conduct, which prohibits a lawyer from acting as both advocate and witness in the same proceeding.
"The fact that Campbell appears as an attorney of record in this appeal lends further credence to our view that Campbell was functioning as a lawyer rather than a witness during the hearing before the MEC," the court wrote.
Despite that, the court said it could affirm the commission's decision based solely on Winbush's own evidence. Her utility bills showed zero water and zero electricity consumed in January 2026 — the period when she was required to reside in Ward 5 to declare her candidacy. A March water bill she submitted showed 600 cubic feet of water usage at the Kings Road home during the time she claimed to be living on Morris Lane.
The court also found Winbush's testimony "vague and difficult to follow," particularly regarding the timing of two moves it said appeared to serve "no apparent purpose other than being able to run for Seat 5."
Winbush's attorney, Chris Kenney, had asked the Supreme Court to expedite the appeal, arguing that Seat 5 has been left without representation and requesting an expedited briefing schedule. The court heard arguments Oct. 14 and issued its ruling Wednesday.
"It's not the result we hoped for," Kenney said.
The case has left the council with eight members and one vacant seat. Winbush's appeal had asked the court to either restore her victory or order a new election.
The court also rejected several of Winbush's arguments as unpreserved, noting they were not raised before the commission. It declined to revisit whether issue preservation rules apply to municipal election commission appeals, citing its earlier decision in Butler v. Town of Edgefield.
The ruling affirmed the commission's finding that Winbush "had not abandoned her residence and domicile at 741 Kings Road at the time she filed to run, or thereafter."
No formal decision has been announced, nor have new filing dates for the office, but the new election is likely to be scheduled for April 6, 2026.