Opinion: Public School Trustees Should Avoid Instructional Classroom Visits

Greg Wilson/Anderson Observer

Anderson School District 5 Trustee Paul Zugg raised a legitimate and deeply troubling concern at Tuesday night's board meeting: school trustees visiting classrooms during instructional time. As a community, we should listen — and the state's own new governance standards back him up.

Zugg, who represents Seat 4, said he wasn't present for the visits in question, but the feedback he received from teachers indicated they felt they were being evaluated by board members. "Speaking personally, I know I would feel the exact same way if my supervisor had someone looking over my shoulder while I was trying to do my job," Zugg said. "Whether a board member offers positive feedback, constructive criticism to a teacher or administrator, it is deeply concerning."

He's right. South Carolina's Department of Education provides evaluator training and certification through the Office of Educator Effectiveness under the South Carolina Teacher Standards 4.0 rubric and the statewide ADEPT system. "To my knowledge, none of us on the board are certified or trained or experts in requiring or evaluating a teacher," Zugg said. "As board members, I feel like we need to stay in our lane. Our role is to govern."

That is not merely Zugg's opinion. It is the explicit command of the State Board of Education's Model Code of Ethics and Effective Board Governance, adopted on third and final reading Nov. 3 under a directive from Act 191. The code draws a firm line between governance and administration: "Effective public education depends upon a clear understanding of the respective responsibilities of the board and superintendent. The board governs; the superintendent administers."

Under the Model Code, the board's job is to establish the district's mission, vision and strategic priorities; adopt policies; employ and annually evaluate the superintendent; adopt and oversee the budget; steward resources; monitor district performance; establish accountability for results; ensure legal compliance; and evaluate its own effectiveness. The superintendent — not individual trustees — administers district operations, implements board policy, supervises personnel, manages finances, advises the board, reports performance and carries out other duties assigned by law or board policy.

The code is equally explicit about limits. Individual board members have no authority to bind the district, supervise employees, direct operations or commit resources except through official board action. Trustees must not administer district operations or direct employees on operational matters. Respecting these roles, as Zugg put it, "keeps this board effective and prevents micromanagement."

Zugg noted that district policy is clear: trustee visits are "only permitted under board authorization and with the full knowledge of the staff, including the superintendent, principals and other supervisors." While the policy permits informal visits after signing in at the front office, Zugg offered a sensible courtesy: "I feel like we live in an era of instant communication. Reaching out to our superintendent prior to an informal visit is a simple, courteous, and respectful" practice "that ensures transparency and trust."

Trustee Bill Thompson, whose visits precipitated the discussion, sees it differently. He cites S.C. Code Section 59-19-90(6), which gives district boards the power and duty to "visit the public schools within its district from time to time and at least once in every school term and take care that they are conducted according to law and with the utmost efficiency." He also points to a June 7, 2001, formal opinion from the South Carolina Attorney General's Office concluding that the plain language of state statute does not require a board member to seek administrative permission before a school visit.

But here is where a crucial distinction must be made — one that too often gets lost in these debates. An opinion letter from an assistant attorney general is not law. It is legal advice to a government agency or official, typically informal and often unpublished. It lacks the force of law, is not binding on courts, and recipients are generally free to follow it or not. A law, by contrast, is a binding rule enacted by the legislature that everyone, including the government, must follow. Legal analysts note that while formal Attorney General opinions are strictly advisory and do not carry the force of binding court rulings, the underlying statute is enacted law.

And even the statute and the 2001 opinion do not explicitly mention instructional classroom visits by name. While observing school operations falls within a trustee's general oversight responsibilities, state governance standards separate observation from administrative authority. The South Carolina School Boards Association's guidelines are clear: individual board members hold no administrative authority outside a legally constituted board meeting. Trustees cannot formally evaluate teachers, critique lessons directly to staff or issue directives to principals and teachers during campus visits.

Districts also must balance statutory visitation rights against operational boundaries, safety protocols and federal privacy laws. A March 12, 2002, follow-up opinion from Assistant Deputy Attorney General Robert D. Cook reaffirmed that federal student privacy rules — including FERPA and IDEA — remain a strict boundary on an individual trustee's access, restricting unscheduled observation in special education or counseling settings absent a board-determined legitimate educational interest.

Superintendent Brenda Kelley welcomed the discussion, saying, "I do appreciate the conversation around this, I really do, because it has caused some dissension within the schools." She noted that "observations in teachers' classroom create" a chilled environment — one in which teachers wonder, "has somebody said something negative about me to a board member, and now a board member is coming to see if I'm doing the right thing or the wrong thing."

“When you're going in, you're inspecting employees,” said Kelley. “Ultimately, is what you're doing. You're supervising employees.”

“With that being said, with the policy, I truly believe, and I'm going to say this: 100%, everybody in here has good intentions. You want to see the great things that are happening in our schools, and you just want to be able to share it. But sometimes, and we have learned and I have learned, the title carries more weight. I have been in this district since I was 13 years old. Unfortunately, the day I took this job on July 1 of 2023, everything I said automatically had a shift. Shift of a weight to it. I literally could say, ‘I can't believe they're putting the Christmas tree up downtown,’ (because) that is shifted to ‘Dr. Kelly, as upset with the City of Anderson for putting the tree up,’ and that's not what I said.”

“The title of a board member will, whether you intend it to be that way or you don't, it carries weight. And when people see you coming in, one, they just want to know: are they coming to see me?”

Kelley added that: “We have great employees, they're wonderful. But when you go into their classroom when they're teaching and their principal doesn't know, I don't know. All they can think is: what has somebody said to them?”

That is the heart of it. A trustee's statutory right to visit schools does not translate into a license to sit in judgment of teachers in their classrooms. The Model Code could not be clearer: "The Board governs. The Superintendent administers." Respect for those distinct responsibilities is "essential to effective governance."

Zugg brought the matter forward "so we can reaffirm our commitment to this policy and respect the professional boundaries of our educators and ensure we are working alongside our superintendent rather than around her."

That is the right course. Trustees who want to observe schools should do so with transparency, courtesy and notice to the superintendent. They should observe — not evaluate, not critique, not direct. And they should remember that an attorney general's opinion letter is advice, not law, and that the state's own governance code tells them plainly to stay in their lane.

Next
Next

S.C. Supreme Court Orders New Election for City Council Seat 5