Greg Wilson/Anderson Observer
More than six months after Anderson voters cast their ballots, the dispute over who should occupy City Council Seat 5 is now before the South Carolina Supreme Court for a decision.
The justices heard arguments Oct. 14 in Tonya Winbush’s challenge to the invalidation of her apparent victory in the April 7 election. The court will now deliberate before issuing a ruling, a process that could take weeks or months, according to Winbush’s attorney, Christopher P. Kenney.
Until then, Anderson City Council remains one member short. City officials have said the district is being temporarily represented by Anderson’s two at-large council members.
The hearing moved the case beyond the briefing and scheduling that occupied much of the summer and early fall, but it did not resolve the central question: whether Winbush met the residency requirements to represent Seat 5.
At issue are two Anderson addresses, competing records of residence and the eligibility of a candidate who finished first at the ballot box.
Winbush maintains that voters elected her over Darryl Thompson by roughly a 2-to-1 margin April 7.
Thompson, the son of retired longtime Councilwoman Beatrice Thompson, challenged Winbush’s residency qualifications two days after the election. His mother’s former seat was the focus of the contest.
On April 17, the Anderson Municipal Election Commission voted to invalidate Winbush’s election. The commission concluded that she had not abandoned her residence at 741 Kings Road, outside the district, despite her assertion that she lived at 309 Morris Lane within Seat 5.
The commission relied on an accumulation of records associated with Kings Road: a deed, Anderson County auditor records, vehicle registrations, utility records and a driver’s license.
Winbush pointed instead to a lease and a water-service application connected to the Morris Lane property.
Winbush has sought to overturn that finding and restore the election result.
Winbush first appealed the municipal commission’s decision to Circuit Court. Following a hearing, the court affirmed the commission in a brief order issued July 7.
She then appealed to the South Carolina Supreme Court and asked that the case be expedited. Kenney, a Columbia attorney, argued that Seat 5 had been left without direct representation and requested a fast briefing schedule similar to those used in earlier election disputes.
The case is listed as Tonya Winbush v. City of Anderson, Anderson Municipal Election Commission, its commissioners and Darryl Thompson. Winbush is the appellant; the city, commission, commissioners and Thompson are respondents.
Kenney represents Winbush. The city, the commission and commissioners David Ford, Clara E. Humphrey and Renee Fields-York are represented by Robert E. Tyson Jr., La’Jessica M. Stringfellow and Sarah Cameron Frierson of Robinson Gray Stepp & Laffitte in Columbia, along with Rame Lambert Campbell and J. Franklin McClain of the Anderson City Attorney’s Office.
Thompson is representing himself.
The court’s decision will determine whether the rulings against Winbush stand or whether she is entitled to relief. The dispute could result in restoration of her election victory, a new election or further proceedings over how the seat is to be filled, depending on the court’s ruling.
For Seat 5 residents, the case has created an extended interval between casting a ballot and knowing who will represent them.